Search
Better Farming OntarioBetter PorkBetter Farming Prairies

Better Farming Ontario Featured Articles

Better Farming Ontario magazine is published 11 times per year. After each edition is published, we share featured articles online.


Farm Products backs dairy board decision to cash in quota

Friday, May 1, 2009

© AgMedia Inc.

by SUSAN MANN

Dairy Farmers of Ontario has sold quota from its quota bank on two separate occasions recently to raise the more than $900,000 in transfer assessment refunds it had to pay several former dairy farmers who won their cases at the Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs Appeal Tribunal.

Former licensed dairy farmer Bill Denby, Sunderland, objects to the commodity organization raising the money this way. Denby is one of those who successfully appealed the DFO’s transfer assessment.

He says the quota in the quota bank belongs to all producers and it wasn’t DFO’s to sell. He wrote to Ontario Agriculture Minister Leona Dombrowsky requesting a public inquiry into both DFO and the Ontario Farm Products Marketing Commission. She referred the matter to the Commission.

The Commission told Denby in a letter signed by chair Geri Kamenz that it found “DFO has acted within its delegated marketing authorities under the Milk Act and that no further investigation into this matter is required.”

Kamenz says the Commission looked to ensure that what the organization did “was consistent with the regulations and the application of the regulations.”

George MacNaughton, director of production and regulatory compliance, says in both cases the farmers involved asked the Tribunal for relief from the organization’s November, 2006 transfer assessment policy.

That policy applies a 15 per cent transfer assessment on all production quota sold on the exchange as of Nov. 17, 2006. The last 10 kilograms of quota is exempt. DFO denied the farmers’ initial requests for relief.

In both cases, the tribunal ordered that the quota sales income lost from the transfer assessment policy be returned in dollars.

MacNaughton says the transfer assessment is collected in kilograms of butterfat. “The only means DFO has to raise the money is to take the kilograms associated with the transfer assessment to generate funds to make the payment.”

Bill Mitchell, the organization’s assistant communications director, says if DFO grants a request for relief from a quota policy, it would normally refund the quota. If the person no longer holds a license, it’s temporarily reactivated so the person can sell the quota.  “In two recent decisions about quota, the direction back from the Tribunal was for a dollar amount rather than quota.”

In a decision delivered in December, 2008, the tribunal ordered DFO to refund, without interest:

•    $153,180 to William and Betty Denby and the estate of John Denby;
•    $139,268 to Dale McFeeters of Woodville; and
•    $511,305.52 to Keith Jarvis and Ron Jarvis of Seagrave.

On March 31, in a different hearing, the Tribunal ordered DFO to refund John and Susanna Cayer of Chesterville $114,492.80 without interest.

The DFO’s board has agreed to pay the Cayers and won’t appeal or request a judicial review. But in the decision of Denby, McFeeters and Jarvis, it has applied for a judicial review. “You ask for a judicial review when you believe that there was an error in law made in a decision,” says Mitchell.

In the meantime, the Tribunal-ordered refund remains in a trust established by the farmers’ lawyers until the review is completed.

Denby says he’s asking the Ontario Ombudsman to investigate both DFO and the Commission. “The Commission is supposed to be the watchdog over the industry and it’s not doing its job.” BF
 

Current Issue

March 2025

Better Farming Magazine

Farms.com Breaking News

Farmer Planting Decisions for 2025 Taking Shape

Thursday, March 13, 2025

As farmers across Canada prepare for the 2025 crop year, Statistics Canada says their planting decisions reflect a complex mix of factors including moisture conditions, crop rotation considerations, and market prices. Nationally, farmers are expected to plant more wheat, corn for... Read this article online

Grain Growers of Sounding the Alarm Over U.S. Tariffs

Monday, March 10, 2025

Not surprisingly, the Grain Growers of Canada (GGC) is raising concerns over the United States' decision to impose a 25% tariff on Canadian grain and grain products, a move that could jeopardize the livelihoods of family-run grain farms and lead to higher food prices for American... Read this article online

International Women’s Day – Angela Cammaert

Wednesday, March 5, 2025

As International Women’s Day approaches on March 8, Farms.com is asking women in ag about what they’d tell their younger selves about being a farmer, to give a piece of advice to young women entering the ag sector, and to highlight a woman in agriculture they consider a mentor or... Read this article online

BF logo

It's farming. And it's better.

 

a Farms.com Company

Subscriptions

Subscriber inquiries, change of address, or USA and international orders, please email: subscriptions@betterfarming.com or call 888-248-4893 x 281.


Article Ideas & Media Releases

Have a story idea or media release? If you want coverage of an ag issue, trend, or company news, please email us.

Follow us on Social Media

 

Sign up to a Farms.com Newsletter

 

DisclaimerPrivacy Policy2025 ©AgMedia Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Back To Top