Search
Better Farming OntarioBetter PorkBetter Farming Prairies

Better Farming Ontario Featured Articles

Better Farming Ontario magazine is published 11 times per year. After each edition is published, we share featured articles online.


Farm employer group 'delighted' by Supreme Court ruling

Friday, April 29, 2011

by SUSAN MANN

Ontario’s Agricultural Employees’ Protection Act is constitutional, the Supreme Court of Canada has ruled.

The decision, released Friday, elated a group that represents farm employers and disappointed the United Food and Commercial Workers Union Canada (UFCW), which argued for years the provincial Act was unconstitutional because it doesn’t require employers to bargain over wage and job conditions and lacks a mechanism to resolve labour disputes.

The Ontario Appeal Court ruled in favour of the union’s argument in November 2008. The province appealed that ruling to the Supreme Court, which heard arguments in December 2009.
 
“We’re officially delighted with the ruling,” says Ken Forth, chair of the agricultural industry’s Labour Issues Coordinating Committee of Friday’s decision.

One justice disagreed with the majority decision but Forth says that’s not a concern. “That’s always the case. That’s why they have nine judges. Eight-to-one is a pretty big win.”

“Farmer workers in Ontario are entitled to meaningful processes by which they can pursue workplace goals,” says Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin and Mr. Justice Louis LeBel in the 8-1 majority written decision posted on the Supreme Court’s website Friday morning. The right of an employees’ association to make representations to their employer and have their views considered in good faith is “a derivative right” under a portion of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and is necessary to the meaningful exercise of the right to free association. The provincial Act, established in 2002, “provides a process that satisfies this constitutional requirement,” the majority of the justices say in the written decision.

The province isn’t required to provide a particular form of collective bargaining rights to agricultural workers “in order to secure the effective exercise of their association rights,” the justices wrote.

Madam Justice Rosalie Silberman Abella, the court’s sole dissenting voice, wrote that the Act doesn’t “protect and was never intended to protect collective bargaining rights.”

Stan Raper, spokesman for UFCW Canada, called the Supreme Court’s decision that Ontario’s Act met the freedom to associate portion of the Canadian Charter, “bad news.”

Madam Justice Abella was the only voice of reason, he says.

Sarah Petrevan, spokesperson for Ontario Agriculture Minister Carol Mitchell, says, the court has endorsed the Act and “so we value that decision.”

Raper says there’s nothing to stop the provincial government from changing the current law to one “that provides basic protection for farm workers.” He says the union will now focus on convincing the province to make the change.

The court has endorsed a portion of the union’s argument that collective bargaining rights were secured in Canada by a previous court decision in British Columbia involving public health workers, he adds. BF
 

Current Issue

March 2025

Better Farming Magazine

Farms.com Breaking News

Farmer Planting Decisions for 2025 Taking Shape

Thursday, March 13, 2025

As farmers across Canada prepare for the 2025 crop year, Statistics Canada says their planting decisions reflect a complex mix of factors including moisture conditions, crop rotation considerations, and market prices. Nationally, farmers are expected to plant more wheat, corn for... Read this article online

Grain Growers of Sounding the Alarm Over U.S. Tariffs

Monday, March 10, 2025

Not surprisingly, the Grain Growers of Canada (GGC) is raising concerns over the United States' decision to impose a 25% tariff on Canadian grain and grain products, a move that could jeopardize the livelihoods of family-run grain farms and lead to higher food prices for American... Read this article online

International Women’s Day – Angela Cammaert

Wednesday, March 5, 2025

As International Women’s Day approaches on March 8, Farms.com is asking women in ag about what they’d tell their younger selves about being a farmer, to give a piece of advice to young women entering the ag sector, and to highlight a woman in agriculture they consider a mentor or... Read this article online

BF logo

It's farming. And it's better.

 

a Farms.com Company

Subscriptions

Subscriber inquiries, change of address, or USA and international orders, please email: subscriptions@betterfarming.com or call 888-248-4893 x 281.


Article Ideas & Media Releases

Have a story idea or media release? If you want coverage of an ag issue, trend, or company news, please email us.

Follow us on Social Media

 

Sign up to a Farms.com Newsletter

 

DisclaimerPrivacy Policy2025 ©AgMedia Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Back To Top