Search
Better Farming OntarioBetter PorkBetter Farming Prairies

Better Farming Ontario Featured Articles

Better Farming Ontario magazine is published 11 times per year. After each edition is published, we share featured articles online.


Accredit NFU-O as a general farm organization, court rules

Friday, October 18, 2013

by SUSAN MANN

The Ontario Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs Appeal Tribunal considered irrelevant factors when it denied accreditation to National Farmers Union–Ontario last year, but the farm group meets the criteria under provincial legislation and should be accredited, an Ontario Superior Court judge has ruled.

Judge Robert N. Beaudoin handed down his decision Oct. 16 after a hearing was held in Ottawa in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice on Sept. 10. NFU-O requested a judicial review of the tribunal’s decision denying it reaccreditation as a general farm organization.

Ontario’s Farm Registration and Farm Organizations Funding Act permits accredited general farm organizations to draw their funding from membership dues that farmers are required to pay each year when they apply for farm business registration. Farmers must pay the dues to an accredited organization of their choice and register their business to become eligible for government-funded business risk programs and several other programs. The membership dues form a major portion of the general farm organizations’ funding.

The Act gives the tribunal the power to award the general farm accreditation.

NFU-O asked the court for an order to set aside the tribunal’s 2012 decision to deny it accreditation. NFU-O also asked for an order directing the tribunal to accredit the organization.

NFU-O president John Sutherland says he’s happy with the decision but he’s also cautious because the tribunal still has time to appeal. In a Thursday news release he further notes “council is pleased with Judge Beaudoin’s decision in our favour, although we are frustrated about having to spend precious resources to obtain a fair assessment about meeting the criteria for re-accreditation."

Sutherland said Thursday night he hadn’t yet reviewed the 24-page decision in detail.

Beaudoin says in his written ruling an order “directing the tribunal to accredit the NFU-O should be issued.”

Mark Cripps, spokesperson for the Ontario Ministry of Agriculture and Food, says the next step in the process is a court order needs to be prepared by NFU-O for the judge to sign.

NFU-O was the successful party in the hearing and it’s the one to write the order, he notes. But the tribunal doesn’t have to wait for the court order to “grant accreditation to NFU-O,” he says.

The tribunal has 15 days from the date Beaudoin’s decision was released to serve notice it’s requesting leave to appeal, Cripps notes.

The tribunal couldn’t be reached for comment.

Cripps says the agriculture minister represented by the Crown law office civil counsel was granted intervener status at the September hearing with the consent of the tribunal and NFU-O. “The minister’s position at the hearing focused on how the Act should be interpreted. This interpretation was adopted by the court.”

Beaudoin says for 10 years the tribunal accepted NFU-O as an organization representing farmers in Ontario and didn’t identify any change in circumstance in its decision being reviewed by the court “that warranted a change in this finding.” NFU-O was first accredited in 2002.

The ministry argued the tribunal considered factors during NFU-O’s 2012 reaccreditation hearing that weren’t among the criteria in the Act for an accreditation application, Beaudoin says. The tribunal looked at:

  • The corporate structure of both the Saskatchewan-based National Farmers Union and NFU-O;
  • The circumstances of NFU-O’s incorporation in 2002;
  • The roles and functions of the corporate officers of each organization;
  • Legal agreements between the two organizations;
  • NFU’s financial statements; and
  • How annual general meetings are conducted.

But the ministry said none of these factors was included as criteria for farm group accreditation under the Act. There’s also nothing in the Act or its regulations authorizing or requiring the tribunal to investigate or make findings on these factors, he says.

The tribunal regarded the NFU/NFU-O relationship as pivotal and characterized it in negative terms, he says.  But the Act doesn’t stop an accredited organization from having an affiliation with a national group.

He notes the tribunal didn’t have the discretion to deny accreditation to NFU-O if the organization met the criteria under the Act “as I have concluded it has done.”

The tribunal argued its finding that NFU-O didn’t meet two of the criteria for reaccreditation was reasonable and was based on detailed oral and verbal evidence obtained during two days of hearings, Beaudoin says.

There’s some urgency to getting NFU-O reaccredited, the judge notes. Delays in dealing with NFU-O’s reaccreditation application in 2012 meant NFU-O’s name didn’t appear on the 2013 farm business registration forms, and the organization “received very little revenue for this calendar year.” The forms for the upcoming registration process are printed in November and if NFU-O isn’t reaccredited its name won’t appear again. That means it won’t receive funding for a second year, making it impossible for the group to continue operating.

Cripps says no court costs were awarded in the case. BF

Current Issue

May 2025

Better Farming Magazine

Farms.com Breaking News

New board members for Ontario Pork

Friday, April 25, 2025

Ontario Pork, an association representing the 1,898 pork farms that market 5.9 million hogs in the province, has announced its new board lineup for 2025. As a Guelph, Ontario-headquartered organization, Ontario Pork is engaged in the areas of research, government representation,... Read this article online

Sheep farmers win Ontario’s Outstanding Young Farmers

Thursday, April 24, 2025

Sheep farmers and wool producers from Wallenstein, Ont. are Ontario’s Outstanding Young Farmers for 2025. “It’s great to be recognized by your peers in the industry with an award like that,” Ryan Schill told Farms.com. “When we started the sheep farm, there were people questioning us... Read this article online

Ontario ag connections in the NHL playoffs

Tuesday, April 22, 2025

The 2025 NHL playoffs are underway, and some of hockey’s biggest names got their start on an Ontario farm or have invested in agriculture since becoming professional athletes. Farms.com went through each of the 16 playoff team rosters to uncover which players have a connection to... Read this article online

New Alcohol Trade Freedom in Ontario

Thursday, April 17, 2025

The Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) has welcomed Ontario’s bold step in eliminating trade barriers and allowing direct alcohol sales to consumers. This new legislation aims to ease internal trade across provinces and support small businesses. One of the key changes... Read this article online

BF logo

It's farming. And it's better.

 

a Farms.com Company

Subscriptions

Subscriber inquiries, change of address, or USA and international orders, please email: subscriptions@betterfarming.com or call 888-248-4893 x 281.


Article Ideas & Media Releases

Have a story idea or media release? If you want coverage of an ag issue, trend, or company news, please email us.

Follow us on Social Media

 

Sign up to a Farms.com Newsletter

 

DisclaimerPrivacy Policy2025 ©AgMedia Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Back To Top